The Journey Continues

Warning: Use of undefined constant fb_layout - assumed 'fb_layout' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /home/customer/www/ on line 386

As I write this I am sitting in the hall behind the Senate chamber with one day left of session.  Two days ago our midwife licensure bill, HB1162, failed to get the 24 votes required to pass. (You can see how Senators voted here.)  Although this is not the outcome we were hoping for, we can take some comfort, that getting us this far in the process – farther than any other CPM bill has advanced in South Dakota – is starting to bring people to the table who were unwilling to work with us in the past.

We are committed to working with those who opposed this year’s bill to come back with a better bill next session.  This year’s work has not been in vain.  It has brought us much closer to our goal.  I am so incredibly grateful for all those moms and dads throughout the state who have been busily contacting legislators and educating them about the need for Certified Professional Midwives in our state.

I am very grateful for all the advice and support we received from the Certified Nurse Midwives who supported HB1162 and for the willingness of the South Dakota Nurses Association to meet with us early in the process and give us suggestions for improving the bill.

I am incredibly grateful for the 70 legislators (54 Representatives and 16 Senators) who voted in support of HB1162 and especially for our amazing prime sponsors Representative Kris Langer from Dell Rapids and Senator Brock Greenfield of Clark.  Please send a quick not of thanks if your legislator was one of the 70 who supported us this year.  (House Tally is here.)  The session is done tomorrow, so this is your last chance to send them an email on their state email address.

We are working on several events this summer.  Our first one is being planned tentatively for Saturday, April 30th at Lake Norden (southwest of Watertown).  This is the home district of our prime senate sponsor Brock Greenfield and we are excited to have him speaking to us about what we can do now to help us pass this next session.  Tentative plans have us meeting for coffee and homemade goodies at 9:30 am followed by a legislative wrap up and a Q & A about this year’s session.  The Hamlin County ladies are amazing cooks and will be providing a Deluxe Taco Bar for our lunch.  During the afternoon session we will have a panel discussion about what everyone can do to help moving forward.  We plan to wrap up the Silent Auction around 4:30 so everyone can be on the road by 5 pm.

We will be asking for a free will donation for the lunch and are planning on a Silent Auction fundraiser as well.  If you are willing to donate something for the Silent Auction, please contact Shannon Zeeb (text or call at 605-695-6030) or join the Facebook Event she started to organize the Silent Auction.

Thanks again for all your efforts this legislative season. Let’s keep the momentum going as we work to promote evidence based options that help families to thrive – including access to skilled midwives in the out of hospital setting.

Debbie Pease
SD Birth Matters

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on The Journey Continues

Home Birth Families Rejoicing in South Dakota

Warning: Use of undefined constant fb_layout - assumed 'fb_layout' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /home/customer/www/ on line 386

Tuesday, February 23 was a huge day for home birth families throughout the state of South Dakota. After nearly 25 years of legislative efforts, the members of the House of Representatives voted 54 – 13 (with 3 excused) to pass HB1162, the bill that would license and regulate Certified Professional Midwives. Representatives Langer, Soli, May, Deutsch, Brunner, Haugaard, Hunt, and Heinemann spoke in favor of the bill and Representative Hunhoff spoke against the bill.

The sentiment was that this is a bill whose time had come. Home births are rising across the country and tripled in South Dakota from 2007 to 2013. The Department of Health’s handout showed that only 56% of home births in the last 5 years were attended by Certified Nurse Midwives, leaving 44% with no provider to care for them. Could this be the reason we are seeing an increased death rate among home birth infants? We believe providing these families access to Certified Professional Midwives could greatly improve these rates.

Even the opposing speaker, praised the efforts of the organization bringing the bill for the way they have persevered and their willingness to work with the opposition. There are still areas of disagreement with the organizations who spoke against the bill, but everyone acknowledged that much progress has been made in addressing their concerns.

Representative Roger Hunt, who was the first legislator to work with home birth families on legislation and who primed many midwife bills during his years in the legislature, asked the members of the body to consider going green as a gift to him on his birthday. After the vote count was read, many legislators burst into applause and someone yelled “Happy Birthday, Roger!” It was a great day to be a midwife supporter at the Capitol.

You can listen to the House Health & Human Services Committee Hearing and the Floor Debate at this link. (click on the blue eagle and fast forward to the time listed)

HB1162 will now be sent to the Senate for consideration where it will be assigned to a committee for a hearing. All bills need to be passed by March 11, the last regular day of session.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Home Birth Families Rejoicing in South Dakota

Midwife Bills Scheduled for Hearings this Week

Warning: Use of undefined constant fb_layout - assumed 'fb_layout' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /home/customer/www/ on line 386

HB1162, the bill to license Certified Professional Midwives will be heard in the House Health and Human Services Committee on Tuesday, February 16, at 7:45 am in Room 412.  We will be offering an amendment that will help clean up the language in this bill and make it more workable for the Board of Nursing.  Those who are not able to make it to Pierre that morning can listen live at the LRC website.

Please contact members of the House Health and Human Services Committee and ask them to support HB1162.

Campbell, Blaine “Chip”
Conzet, Kristin
Deutsch, Fred
DiSanto, Lynne
Greenfield, Lana
Haugaard, Steven
Heinemann, Leslie
Holmes, Thomas
McCleerey, Steven
Munsterman, Scott
Sly, Jacqueline
Soli, Karen
Wollmann, Mathew

If HB1162 passes out of the House HHS Committee as amended, it should be scheduled for its second reading and a debate on the House floor on Thursday, February 18th.  Please contact your legislators on Wednesday and let them know that HB1162 made it out of committee and respectfully request their “Yes” vote on the floor.

SB117, our bill to allow Certified Professional Midwives who are licensed in other states to practice in South Dakota, is scheduled for a hearing in the Senate Health and Human Services Committee on February 19th.  If HB1162 passes the House, we will withdraw SB117.  If HB1162 does not pass the House we will go forward with the hearing for SB117 on the 19th.  Please be ready to contact the Senators on the Senate HHS committee, Thursday after session if necessary.

Bradford, Jim
Curd, R. Blake
Heinert, Troy
Jensen, Phil
Rampelberg, Bruce
Rusch, Arthur
Shorma, William

Please sign up for our Email Alerts and follow us on Facebook to get the latest news on these bills.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Midwife Bills Scheduled for Hearings this Week

Maternity Care Shortages in SD

Warning: Use of undefined constant fb_layout - assumed 'fb_layout' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /home/customer/www/ on line 386

We’ve created a new handout that demonstrates the gaps in maternity care in SD and how far some women need to drive to access maternity providers. Please feel free to share this with your community and your legislators!

Provider Shortage Handout–Printable PDF

Provider Shortage

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Maternity Care Shortages in SD

Advocacy Day Slideshow

Warning: Use of undefined constant fb_layout - assumed 'fb_layout' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /home/customer/www/ on line 386

Thanks to everyone who helped make our Birth Matters Legislative Advocacy a success! We appreciate everyone who contributed to and helped us serve our Healthy Birth Luncheon to the legislators.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Advocacy Day Slideshow

Thanks For Your Help!

Warning: Use of undefined constant fb_layout - assumed 'fb_layout' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /home/customer/www/ on line 386

Advocacy Day is Huge Success

Nearly 50 Birth Matters supporters ventured to the Capitol on January 19th to visit with legislators and serve them lunch in the Capitol Rotunda.  We are extremely grateful to everyone who helped in anyway to make this such a successful event.  Thank you so much for your donations of time, food and financial gifts as well as your continued prayers.

Today we will be collecting signatures of sponsors on our two bills.  We anticipate that the Licensure Bill will get a number by midweek – so watch for a message when that happens.  At that point, we will send you a link, so you can read it online.  We expect the Decriminalization Bill to get it’s number the following week.

After the bills get their numbers, they will be assigned to a committee, where we will be allowed to offer testimony.  It would be wonderful to have supporters attend those committee meetings in person.  We will give you as much advanced notice as we can as to when those meetings will occur.  If we get the majority of legislators on the committee to vote “Yes” on our bill, then it goes to the full body to vote on – usually a day or two later.  If it passes, then it gets sent to the other chamber, where it will be assigned to a committee and go through a similar process.  If it passes both houses, it gets sent to the Governor for his signature.

We are at the beginning of an exciting journey that could end with a new law to allow our families access to Certified Professional Midwives.  We will do our best to keep you updated every step of the way, so that you can do all you can to contribute to the efforts.  Thanks in advance for all your help!

For those of you who came to Pierre, this is a great time to send a thank you note to any legislator who took the time to visit with you.  You can enjoy some great pictures of the day on our South Dakota Birth Matters Facebook Page.

Thank you to everyone who made our 2016 Legislative Lunch and Advocacy Day such a success!
Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Thanks For Your Help!

Home Birth Safety Recognized

Warning: Use of undefined constant fb_layout - assumed 'fb_layout' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /home/customer/www/ on line 386

Written by Heather Siebert

Overwhelming support for the safety of home birth with a midwife has recently been reported in two major studies, one conducted in the UK and another in Canada. In fact, these paradigm-shifting publications provide robust evidence that home births are as safe as, if not safer than, births in a traditional hospital setting.  Another, much smaller, US study that was not specific to midwives was also recently published and while it showed an increased risk in perinatal mortality in out-of-hospital births, it emphasized that absolute risks in both settings are very low.

United Kingdom’s NICE demonstrates home birth safety

The idea that the hospital is the best location for birth is examined in a landmark press release published by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), an advisory entity for the United Kingdom’s National Health System.

The NICE publication makes two primary claims based upon evidence from 17,000 home births included in the UK’s population health data conducted by Birthplace:

  1. Midwife-led units, such as a birth center (freestanding) or a unit within the hospital (alongside) are safer than a traditional hospital setting with care by an OBGYN for women with “straightforward” pregnancies;
  2. Home births are just as safe as midwife-led units and traditional hospitals for women who have “straightforward” pregnancies and have given birth before.

What is a straightforward pregnancy?

A “straightforward” pregnancy is one in which there are no complications such as high blood pressure or gestational diabetes; the mother is considered low-risk for complications. While some may be surprised to learn this, in fact most women fall into this category. Dr. Baker, NICE’s clinical practice director is quoted as saying, “Most women are healthy and have straightforward pregnancies and births.”

What safety issues are avoided by giving birth at home?

Dr. Neel Shah, assistant professor of Obstetrics, Gynecology, and Reproductive Health at Harvard Medical School, examined the NICE recommendations, recognizing differences in treatment intensity between traditional hospital treatment and midwifery care. His response was published in June 2015 by the New England Journal of Medicine. Shah explained that obstetricians are trained as surgeons and are surrounded by operating rooms. Read his description of hospital birth:

Nearly all Americans are currently born in settings that are essentially intensive care units (ICUs): labor floors have multipaneled telemetry monitors, medications that require minute-by-minute titration, and some of the highest staffing ratios in the hospital. Most labor floors are actually more intensive than other ICUs in that they contain their own operating rooms.

There are dangers to over-intervention. Greene and Ecker write in a December 2015 editorial published in the New England Journal of Medicine that interventions have not demonstrated their worth; for example, the cesarean rate has doubled since the 1970s but the fetal death rate has not changed.  Because of this, “…It is easy to see them [interventions] as unnecessary, meddlesome, and unacceptable.” Obstetricians are much more likely than midwives to routinely intervene with the birth process through inducing labor, electronic fetal monitoring, episiotomy, and cesarean birth, causing greater and perhaps unnecessary discomfort for women and increasing the risk of further interventions. Additionally, the risk for hospital-acquired infection increases. To top it off, Dr. Shah from the Harvard Medical School admits that birth interventions are rarely helpful to the newborn baby.

To put it simply: birthing with a midwife gives mothers peace of mind that their safety will not be compromised though routine, unnecessary intervention. Their uncomplicated pregnancies do not require ICU attention.

NICE recommendations

The UK’s NICE recommends mothers should have the option to birth with a midwife, whether at home or in a midwife-led unit. Healthcare providers should respect a mother’s choice if she decides to birth under the care of a midwife. Here in the United States, NICE recommendations are initiating important conversations about medicalized birth and treatment intensity in the US, reports Wang in a September 2015 Wall Street Journal article.

McMaster University researchers find home birth as safe as hospital birth

The Canadian Medical Association Journal published an article on December 22, 2015 comparing 11,493 planned home births to 11,493 planned hospital births. The study was conducted by researchers from McMaster University (Ontario); it found that home births, under the care of a midwife, showed no increased risk of harm to the baby compared to hospital births.

The McMaster University researchers included both first-time mothers and women who had previously given birth in their study. All women had low-risk pregnancies.

Eileen Hutton, a professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology at McMaster’s School of Medicine, is quoted as saying, “Among women who intended to birth at home with midwives, the risk of stillbirth, neonatal death or serious neonatal morbidity was low and did not differ from midwifery clients who chose hospital birth.”

As illustrated in the NICE publication, this study showed that women who gave birth at home were less likely to have interventions such as induction or labor augmentation, assisted vaginal birth, or cesarean delivery. The home birth mothers were also more likely to be exclusively breastfeeding at 3 and 10 days after delivery.

Small US study is not specific to midwives

On December 31, 2015, The New England Journal of Medicine published a study comparing outcomes for low-risk mothers in Oregon who planned to give birth in the hospital (75,923) with low-risk mothers who planned to give birth out-of-hospital (3,203) in the years 2012 and 2013.    This study agreed with the other studies in finding that those giving birth out-of-hospital experienced much lower intervention rates including induction and cesarean section as well as lower admissions to NICU units. The study also showed that those planning out-of-hospital births were more likely to give birth at full term.  Unlike the larger Canadian and UK studies, this study was not specific to licensed midwives – 90% of the births were with licensed providers (Naturopathic Doctor 13%, Certified Nurse Midwife 20%, Licensed Direct-Entry Midwife 57%); 10% of the births were with unlicensed providers (unlicensed midwives 8% and other person, such as a relative 2%). The Oregon study showed a higher risk of perinatal mortality for planned out-of-hospital births, although the authors emphasized that the absolute risk for both groups was still very low.

Home birth is a good option for low-risk women

While there are no risk-free locations to have a baby, these studies show that for low-risk women, there are many benefits to choosing an out-of-hospital birth with a skilled midwife.  The lower intervention rates and higher breastfeeding rates experienced by those families planning out-of-hospital births, not only save them money but may help them maintain lower risks in subsequent births.

Could the slightly higher perinatal mortality rates experienced by out-of-hospital births in Oregon be attributed to a lack of established transfer protocols and respect and cooperation between hospital staff and home birth providers?  We need to continue to explore how birth can be improved for all families in all locations.

Improving South Dakota outcomes

Our current policy in South Dakota of prohibiting our families from accessing Certified Professional Midwives, the only US healthcare provider that has required training in out-of-hospital maternity care, is leaving dangerous gaps in care in many parts of the state.  Home birth friendly countries like Canada and the UK and home birth friendly states like Alaska, Montana and Oregon have better perinatal outcomes than South Dakota.  It is time we join the 30 other states who safeguard the practice of these highly skilled midwives for their citizens.


Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Home Birth Safety Recognized

Did Mary Have a Midwife?

Warning: Use of undefined constant fb_layout - assumed 'fb_layout' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /home/customer/www/ on line 386

Merry Christmas from SD Birth Matters

As we prepare to celebrate the birth of Christ, I’m wondering what it was like for Mary being so far away from home for the birth of her child.  Did she have the help of a local midwife or did she and Joseph birth “unassisted” by other humans?  Like Mary, many women in South Dakota today do not have the option to have their baby in the safety of their own home with a trusted midwife.  Although Certified Nurse Midwives are allowed by law to assist at home births, very few choose to do so and most practice only near Sioux Falls and Rapid City, leaving the families in the rest of the state on their own.

The evidence continues to mount that our cultural norm of high-tech birth practices is not beneficial to most babies and moms.  Interventions like fetal monitoring, induction and cesareans that were developed for high-risk births are now being used on many women with healthy pregnancies.  As rates of cesareans and inductions have risen, so has the number of babies that are being born premature.  And although our high-tech health care system heroically intervenes to save younger and younger babies, it seems a more effective solution would be to prevent the problem in the first place.

We are incredibly grateful that, at the encouragement of our South Dakota Department of Health, every hospital with maternity services in our state has agreed to a policy of no elective inductions before 39 weeks.  This seems like such a common sense policy, but I have heard grumblings from some parents who don’t understand why they can no longer schedule their baby’s birth.  We need to keep educating parents about the benefits of this policy.

When procedures are done for convenience rather than medical necessity, we end up with higher rates of injury and death to babies and their moms.  The Midwives Model of Care has been proven to reduce the incidence of birth injury, trauma, and cesarean section.  That is why South Dakota Birth Matters is so passionate about increasing the number of skilled midwives practicing in South Dakota.

This year we will be bringing 2 bills to the South Dakota State Legislature that would give South Dakota families access to Certified Professional Midwives (CPMs), the experts in out-of-hospital birth.  Plan A is a licensure bill that will take a 2/3 vote to pass.  Plan B decriminalizes the practice of midwifery for Certified Professional Midwives licensed in other states and student midwives under the supervision of an approved preceptor.  You can read more about these bills at  Our goal is to increase the safety for those families in our state who choose to have their babies at home by giving them access to licensed professionals who are held to evidence-based practice standards.  Plan A holds those midwives accountable to a board within our state. Plan B does not.

We will not be able to get one of these bills passed without your help.  We have a dedicated leadership team who is working to get you the resources you need to network with all your acquaintances and make a huge impact on the legislators.  Here are 4 easy steps you can take right now to make a difference:

  1. Send a handwritten note to your 3 legislators asking them to support the Midwife Bills (how to info here).  Your legislators want to hear from you!  A handwritten note now will pave the way for future communications as our bills make their way through the process.
  2. Get active on our Facebook Page (links below).  The more people who like, share, and comment, the more our message gets spread to others.  Even just a one word comment, really helps boost a post.
  3. Help with our Advocacy Day on January 19th.  There are lots of ways you can help listed on our online sign-up sheet.  If you can’t come or send food, please send a financial donation to help cover expenses (any amount is greatly appreciated).
  4. Ask at least one other person to take these steps with you.

None of us can do it all, but all of us can do something.  Working together we are making a difference.  Thank you in advance for the steps you are taking to help provide better birth options for South Dakota families!

May you and your family have a very Merry Christmas!
Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Did Mary Have a Midwife?

Join Us at the Capitol on January 19th

Warning: Use of undefined constant fb_layout - assumed 'fb_layout' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /home/customer/www/ on line 386
Your help is needed to make our 2016 Legislative Advocacy Day the best ever.  South Dakota Birth Matters will have a display set up in the Capitol Rotunda all day and serve lunch to the legislators there from 11 am to 1 pm.  There will be time for you to visit with legislators, attend committee hearings and watch both the House and Senate while in floor session. (We will post more details as we get closer.)You can sign up to:

  • bring food,
  • help with set up,
  • help with clean up,
  • serve as our photographer
  • serve the meal, or
  • provide childcare 

at our online volunteer site. You can also let us know if you need childcare, which will be available from 9 am to 3:30 pm in the Visitors Center (right next to the Capitol) for a free will offering.  Please post on our Facebook Event if you are interested in ride shares from your area or staying with a host family in Pierre.

If you can’t come, but still want to help, we need your financial support to pay for things like facility rental, bottled water, juice, and paper products.  Any amount is greatly appreciated!  You can donate to our Paypal Account on the home page of our website  or send a check to :
South Dakota Birth Matters
Julie Pease, Treasurer
1200 N Advantage
This picture is a throwback from our 2008 Advocacy Day.  We are still here fighting to give South Dakota families access to the birth options that are working well in other states.  This year our focus is on licensing Certified Professional Midwives – the experts in out of hospital birth.  Certified Professional Midwives have been recognized in 30 states. None of these states has ever rescinded their laws, because these midwives are providing a valuable service and saving families and states money.Join us in bringing Certified Professional Midwives to South Dakota!


Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Join Us at the Capitol on January 19th

Midwife Bills for 2016 Legislative Session

Warning: Use of undefined constant fb_layout - assumed 'fb_layout' (this will throw an Error in a future version of PHP) in /home/customer/www/ on line 386

South Dakota Birth Matters is working on two bills for the 2016 legislative session to give South Dakota families access to Certified Professional Midwives

Licensure Bill
This bill sets up an advisory committee under the Board of Nursing to license and regulate Certified Professional Midwives. It is modeled after the statute that regulates Certified Nurse Midwives (SDCL 36-9A) and contains the language regarding educational requirements from the historic US MERA agreement.

What is US MERA?
Last year, all of the major US midwifery education and credentialing bodies got together and agreed upon language for Certified Professional Midwife licensure. This language sets standards for education that meet the criteria set by the International Confederation of Midwives (ICM).

Why does that matter?
It matters because the national office of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists now officially support the ICM education and training standards. The language in our new bill meets those standards.

“The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) endorses the ICM education and training standards and strongly advocates the ICM criteria as a baseline for midwife licensure in the United States, through legislation and regulation.  Women in every state should be guaranteed care that meets these      important minimum standards…All midwives – whatever their title or professional designation and             regardless of where they practice – should meet the ICM standards, to ensure access to safe, qualified,   highly skilled midwives in all settings including birth centers.”

Companion document to the ACOG Policy Statement on Midwifery Education and Certification and the Obstetric Care Consensus document, Levels of Maternal Care, developed jointly by ACOG and the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine, April 20, 2015  Link to ACOG Statement

Decriminalization Bill
Some may argue that we do not have enough Certified Professional Midwives currently practicing or willing to practice in our state to warrant passing a licensure bill. This decriminalization bill would create a bridge to licensure by doing 3 things:

Section 1 allows Certified Professional Midwives who are licensed in other states, and student midwives under the direct supervision of an approved preceptor to practice in South Dakota. This is accomplished by adding them to the exemptions listed in the nurse midwife practice act (36-9A-3).

Section 2 of the bill calls for the repeal of Section 1 on July 1, 2020.

Section 3 establishes the Midwife Regulation Fund where voluntary contributions can be collected and used for initial costs of setting up a regulatory board or advisory committee to regulate Certified Professional Midwives.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Midwife Bills for 2016 Legislative Session